Conclusion: A Bold Bet on Community Over Commerce. Find out more about Maui short term rental phase out economic consequences.

The enactment of Bill 9 on December 15/16, 2025, marks one of the most significant legislative shifts in Maui County’s recent memory. It is an explicit declaration that the right to a stable, long-term home for residents outweighs the short-term economic yield of unrestrained transient accommodation in residential zones. The data is clear: the trade-off is severe—a potential $900 million hit to visitor spending and 1,900 jobs lost, balanced against the immediate potential of over 6,000 homes becoming available, equivalent to a decade of development. Furthermore, the real estate market is poised for a long-awaited correction. The question for the next few years isn’t whether the economic impact will be felt—it will be profound—but whether the societal return on investment justifies the turbulence. How effectively the county manages the transition, mitigates the tax fallout, and successfully integrates thousands of new residents into the local fabric will define the success of this defining moment. What are your thoughts on the staggered implementation timeline? Do you believe the anticipated drop in condominium prices will be enough to offset the significant projected losses in visitor revenue? Share your perspective below and let us know what you think the county should prioritize in the next six months to ensure a smooth transition.